Some time ago someone left a rude comment to one of my posts, asking the
question (at rather more length) of how an apparently rational person like
me can believe in all this Christian nonsense. I was in a bad mood at
the time, and merely pointed out his comment as an example of how not to
win friends and influence people. Still, it seems to me that he deserves
a real answer, not just an ill-tempered grimace.
The short answer is that by the grace of God I cannot do other than
believe.
I don’t expect any non-believers in my audience to find this answer
terribly helpful, but nonetheless it’s true.
Here’s the long answer.
The first point is that (from an intellectual point of view) Christianity
isn’t nonsense, but rather a belief-system capable of being rationally
defended. Indeed, it was St. Thomas Aquinas’ view (so I am given to
understand) that the propositions of the Christian faith are susceptible
to rigorous logical proof–with the minor problem that the details are so
lengthy and intricate that few men or women will ever have the time (or
make the effort) to follow them. I mention to this say that this most
certainly isn’t the way I came to belief in Christ.
However, even without going to such lengths, I still claim that it is
rational to believe in Christ. Indeed, what’s the basis for claiming
that it’s irrational? There’s only one, and that’s materialistic
atheism–the claim, in short, that only the natural exists; any
belief in the supernatural is nothing more than superstition.
Abler writers than myself have disposed of this; I can recommend
C.S. Lewis,
especially Mere Christianity and Surprised by Joy (Lewis,
I may say, is the clearest thinker I’ve had the pleasure to read.), as
well as G.K.
Chesterton, particularly Orthodoxy and The Everlasting
Man.
And the point is this: the claim that the supernatural does not and
cannot exist is a statement of faith, not a scientific truth. It is,
in fact, the statement that nothing contrary to the Laws of Nature has
ever been manifest in the universe, from the beginning of time until
now. Can you see the flaw? The Laws of Nature are taken as a given,
as an immutable fact, when in fact our knowledge of them changes
with each advancement of science. As I say, it’s a statement of faith; and
interestingly, it’s a faith that affirms, a priori, that any
counter-examples can be discounted without investigation.
On the other hand, just because I accept that supernatural events might
in fact occur, and believe that they have occurred in the past, it
doesn’t necessarily follow that I’ve jettisoned my critical faculties
altogether, or that I’m a credulous fool who believes six impossible
things before breakfast. My worldview takes in things that the
scientistic (note–not scientific, but scientistic)
worldview does not, but I still don’t believe things without reason.
So what’s my reason? Why do I believe in Jesus Christ, the Son of God,
the crucified and resurrected and living messiah?
The answer is simple. I’ve met him. I no more need proofs that Jesus
exists than I need proofs that my wife Jane exists.
I grew up Roman Catholic, and so I was first introduced to Jesus at an
early age. But you know how it is when you’re little and you meet your
parent’s friends. No matter how often you see them, you never really
know them. And then, by the time I was a senior in High School, God had
begun to seem like a really bad idea–a nuisance, an inconvenience, a bad
excuse for living with everlasting guilt. I decided that I was, if not an
outright atheist, at least an agnostic. I didn’t want to know God. I
didn’t want there to be a God. I wanted there not to be a God.
Baldy put, my disbelief had nothing to do with any intellectual or
rational process, but only with a desire to avoid the consequences of
God’s existence. Which is rather pathetic, when you come to think about
it.
Anyway, the change came shortly after Christmas during my senior year of
high school. I attended a Christian rock concert–a friend, likewise agnostic,
had been invited by yet another friend, who was a Christian; the first
friend wanted company and invited me. I wasn’t especially interested, but
I was bored and it was something to do. And during the evening I was
asked, as part of the present company, to make a decision for or against
Christ.
Really, you can’t be too careful. Lack of faith has to be nurtured
lovingly, or the incalculable may happen.
For that’s when I heard the Lord speaking to me. I don’t mean that I
heard actual spoken words; it was very much in the stillness of my head.
And it didn’t really come in the form of words; it was more of an
impression. More, as Chesterton would say, of a Presence. But the
message came through clearly:
Will, you know perfectly well I’m here. Are you going to acknowledge me,
or are you going to live in denial for the rest of your life?
And the plain truth is that that still small voice was correct. Whatever I
might tell myself, and whatever the desires of my heart, I did know. And
I felt I was really being given a choice–if I elected to live in denial,
God would honor that decision. Or I could acknowledge him, and accept
the consequences.
I have no way of knowing what would have happened if I had chosen to
reject God that night. I expect that I would have persisted in my denial,
and I further expect that at best I’d have turned into a mordant,
sarcastic, bitter, sorry excuse for a human being. I’m sure that I’d
have come to hate Christianity with a passion; that, after all, would be
the human thing to do.
God be thanked, I didn’t go that way. Instead, I admitted to myself that
God exists, and that he is Lord–that is, that he has a claim on me.
That his opinion matters. And that was the first step. That was the
beginning of my knowledge of God. It was a small step–there was so much
I didn’t understand–but an essential one.
Since then, my friendship with God has had its share of ups and downs.
I’ve had bleak depressions, and upon occasion I’ve had “Jordan
moments”, times when Jesus was so present to me it was as though he were
sitting next to me. And now I know him…I won’t say “well”, but
certainly much better than I did on that long ago night. And no matter
how bleak my mood or enormous my doubts, there’s one thing I’ve always
been sure of. No matter how unlikely it seems at times, I know that God
is there. He told me so himself.
He’ll tell you the same, if you ask him.